Comments on: How to Choose the Best Photo Editing Software: 10 Things to Consider

By: Klaus Mohr

Klaus Mohr — Sat, 29 Apr 2023 18:45:20 +0000

Wie meinst du das: “…Und es gibt keinen echten Importeur…” ?
Ich kenne lediglich 3 Anwendungen, die eine vernünftige Importfunktion bieten, die automatische Umbenennungen, Zielordnerzuweisungen per Token und andere Funktionen haben, die sich gemeinsam als Importvorlage speichern lassen, sodass für verschiedene Import-Situationen nur die jeweilige Vorlage gewählt werden muss.

1. Lightroom Classic
2. Zoner Photo Studio X
3. ON1 Photo RAW 2023. Oder hast du den Menüpunkt “Datei > Von Gerät importieren…” noch nicht gefunden? Oder verstehst du unter “echter Importeur” etwas anderes als ich?

By: Justin Martin

Justin Martin — Tue, 25 Apr 2023 22:56:46 +0000

For me, ON1 fails on Point 3. I’ve been a long-time user (~10 years give or take) and mid last year committed to using it as my primary editing tool. I have now gone back to Lightroom. The performance is awful, taking up to 8 seconds to load a photo and it is worse if you have applied NoNoise. I have a well spec’d laptop and get no issues with other software.

I would also add a point 11 which is stability/reliability and ON1 is questionable. In an effort to solve the performance issues, Support have recommended in the past to completely remove ON1 and reinstall clean. I did this recently and ON1 is worse than ever. Crashing on regular occasions (often quitting with no error message) and once it even completely deleted a folder of photos to the point I had to restore from a backup.

I wish they would address the issues that are clearly the product before adding more features.

By: brian.stott

brian.stott — Sun, 23 Apr 2023 19:03:59 +0000

In reply to Andreas Pohl. I find the DAM in On1 is the same as your computer file system so you know how it works with no learning curve, I am using a IMac so cannot comment on a windows platform. But On1 seems the most intuitive software I have come across.

By: Andreas Pohl

Andreas Pohl — Sun, 23 Apr 2023 18:37:22 +0000

Unfortunately, I don’t see ON1 Photo RAW fulfill point 5 Organization & Management as it lacks major digital asset management (DAM) features.
Especially working with albums isn’t flexible at all. And there is no real importer.
That’s what prevents me from switching from Capture One to ON1 completely.
For importing, organizing and DAM C1 is way better, editing is way better with ON1. I hope one of these 2 tools will offer a holistically best package soon, so I can drop the other one.

Furthermore annoying bugs like iOS video thumbnails displayed upside down don’t get fixed by ON1..